A release ofthe Seckler family that owns Purdue was overturned by a federal judge late lastyear. Estimated to be approximately 63% of the value of the Abuse Claim. Arizona You will receive a link to create a new password via email. A federal bankruptcy court in Delaware signaled July 29 that the long-running Chapter 11 bankruptcy of the Boy Scouts of America may nearly be finished. They also show up in the latest plan filed by Purdue Pharma, which entered bankruptcy in 2019 amid thousands of lawsuits claiming Oxycontin marketing spurred the opioid epidemic. The industry leader for online information for tax, accounting and finance professionals. The case is In re Boy Scouts of America, U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware, No. The following article will discuss whats happening now with this case and how much money you can expect to receive from your lawsuit payout when it does arrive. Before the end of the voting period, Boy Scouts announced thatcongregations affiliated with the United Methodist Church had agreed to contribute $30 million to the victims' trust. Silverstein ruled in July that the settlement was not the result of collusion or bad faith. The future of that settlement remains uncertain. Boy Scouts mustpresent its youth protection program, along with proposed changes, to the committee for three years. State laws may affect the amount that an abuse survivor could expect to receive on account of his claim in litigation outside of bankruptcy. The Boy Scouts of America filed a plan to set aside $2.7 billion to pay about 92,000 or more former Scouts who were abused for their pain and suffering. Call us today at 434-535-5229 or just upload you proof of claim or answer the questions on this page to start the pre-settlement lawsuit loan process. A redline version of the Current Plan, which shows changes made to the immediately preceding plan dated December 18, 2021 (the "December Plan"), is attached. But we dont fund Boy Scout cases right now.. The Boy Scouts of America's national organization has agreed to contribute $250 million to the fund, The New York Times reported. 15:46 - Application of Claims Matrix and Scaling Factors. UNPRECEDENTED: Nearly 90,000 file sexual abuse claims against the Boy Scouts. The proposal outlines a range of possible payments, from $3,500 for sexual abuse that involved no touching, to as much as $2.7 million for sexual penetration by an adult perpetrator and other . Please answer the two questions below and press the button to see the TCC's estimate of the average recovery for this type of claim. . Copyright Pfau Cochran Vertetis Amala PLLC All Rights Reserved 2020. At issue is whetherclaims that are time-barred under statutesof limitations will be eligible for payouts. We now know that theres a path forward and we can close this fairly soon and we can start to get some closure, one man said of abuse he suffered in 1973. New Hampshire Any mentions of loans, lending, interest, or other terms related to loans on this website are only there for marketing reasons. The typical split is 60/40 minus a 1-2% fee divided by the claimants as a whole. Hearing scheduled for 3/3/2023 at 10:00 AM at US Bankruptcy Court, 824 Market St., 6th Fl., Courtroom Wilmington, Delaware. Maryland All Rights Reserved. Masturbation Claim Yet,it remains unclear how the plan would get anywhere close to Boy Scouts' own estimation of thevalue of theclaims, which they say isbetween $2.4 billion and $7.1 billion. On Dec. 13, an $800 million settlement was announced with another of Boy Scouts' primary insurers, Century Indemnity Co.. Also included is an additional $40 million from local councils, upping . Abuse survivors may elect an expedited one-time cash payment of $3,500 if the survivor does not wish to have his claim fully evaluated by the Settlement Trust. There, payments could reach $48,000 for opioid-related death. Scouts have nothing that comprehensive. (Akkerman, Levi). But the pre-settlement loan amount is completely dependent on the strength of the case. Prosecutor says only South Carolina attorney Murdaugh could have murdered wife and son, Ghislaine Maxwell seeks to throw out sex trafficking conviction in Epstein case, China scoffs at FBI claim that Wuhan lab leak likely caused COVID pandemic, EU silence over Pfizer COVID contract talks is problem that won't go away -watchdog, Western US cities vote to move ahead with novel nuclear power plant, Activision fired staff for using 'strong language' about remote work policy -union, Law firm leaders express the benefit of strategy, culture & adaptability to weather these uncertain times, 2023 State of the Courts Report: Moving toward modernization, US enforcement seeks fraud among emerging, unregulated finance spaces, Recommended change management practices to plan, build, then deploy successful legal tech, Exclusive news, data and analytics for financial market professionals. Statutes vary across states, creating a unique circumstance for a national organization such as the Boy Scouts. Kentucky 20-10343. for a $3,500 expedited payment, which would . Representatives for the insurers and the Boy Scouts did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Compare that to asbestos claims. The payments will be made on a rolling basis so that some people may receive their payments earlier than others. The future of that settlement remains uncertain. The court has gotten a preview of what the trustee will see in letters from thousands of abuse survivors. Objections due by 2/28/2023. Victims should be able to sue those organizations instead of being forced to seek payment from the Boy Scouts' bankruptcy settlement fund, which will not pay their claims in full, Dumas said. One person the bankruptcy trustee will make the decisions, guided by criteria within a plan from the Boy Scouts that must be approved by all parties involved and a bankruptcy judge. "When Boy Scouts filed a nationwide bankruptcy, they forced every survivor around the country to file a claim," said Jason Amala, an attorney who represents sex abuse survivors. 00:00 - General Overview. 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Battle brews over NY Boy Scout cabin used by young JFK, Boy Scout comforted dying truck driver after Amtrak derailment, father says, Black bear bites 12-year-old Scout during camping trip in upstate park, Florida woman stole $10,000 from Boy Scouts Europe trip fund: cops, Abortions in Texas fell 60% in 1st month under new limits, 11-year-old reads aloud from 'pornographic' book he checked out from library at school board meeting, Influencer refuses to switch business class seats so family can sit together, Top NFL prospect racing, driving recklessly in crash that killed teammate, staffer: cops, 10 celebrity-loved skincare buys from Dermstores Beauty Refresh Sale, Watch Travis Scott explode at DJ: Back the fk up, Fking heartless Kristin Cavallari admits to recently dumping guy via text, Good luck 'worming' your way out of this one, Sunny Hostin Points Finger at China for COVID Crisis: Did Not Cooperate With the International Community, Meghan Markle, Prince Harry have first night out since bombshell 'Spare' released. Idaho The insurers said the settlement prevents them from raising typical defenses, such as arguing that claims filed in the bankruptcy case would be time-barred in the states where they were filed. The Boy Scouts filed for bankruptcy in February 2020 to address lawsuits filed by thousands of men who say they were abused as children by troop leaders. You may file a civil suit using Arizonas open look-back window. With these amounts, the BSA's proposed global settlement fund would be approximately $2.4 billion. Though you may not receive compensation, your abuser will be on legal public record. Name * Email * Phone. In graphic detail, they describe being blindfolded and stripped naked at jamborees in the woods of Appalachia, pinned down in showers at camps in the Midwest or raped in tents in the desert while others watched the shadows cast against the tent walls. The Trustee also objected to the payment of certain professional fees which it said fall outside of bankruptcy code. Removing duplicates was the first and easiest task, dropping the total to 82,500. (LJJ), HEARING RESCHEDULED. The Boy Scouts of America have struck a deal to pay $850 million to survivors who experienced sexual assault by scoutmasters or other leaders as part of its bankruptcy proceedings. Of the 510 sexual abuse claims filed against it, 450 allege abuse by a single person: team doctor Larry Nassar. They also offered support to victims through monetary assistance and funding for counseling sessions. Texas Insurers argue that any plan requiring them to pay those claims violates both their policies and bankruptcy code because lawsuits on those same claims wouldn't be viablein civil court. 2023 ECO Pre-settlement Funding. For this reason, the proposed procedures for paying claims under the Settlement Trust take into account relevant state laws, including statutes of limitation or repose. The Settlement Trust Assets, including the proceeds of the There's an effort to change that. Hearing scheduled for 3/3/2023 at 10:00 AM at US Bankruptcy Court, 824 Market St., 6th Fl., Courtroom Wilmington, Delaware. Do you have mesothelioma? By Maria Chutchian. More: Boy Scouts abuse claims may become largest case against a single national organization. Comments. Delaware Images provided on this website are for personal, non-commercial use. An unusual provision in the Scouts plan would allow claimants to wait for up to a year to see if the laws in their state change in their favor. 08:00 - Flow Chart and Trust Claim Process Overview. Jan. 5, 2022. In sexual abuse cases, bankruptcy court judges who make the final decision typically have been looking for agreater level of support. 20-10343. Currently, there is no fixed date for the payout, its still not clear how much longer it will take for the Boy Scouts lawsuits to be resolved and payments to be made. We helped lead the opposition to the BSAs first proposed bankruptcy plan, which was voted down by survivors. In its analysis of the plan, USA TODAY found Scouts identified 59,000 71% as potentially too late under state statutes. You can read more about the TCC's estimates by clicking here (save the document and then start reading on page 35), including other reasons why the TCC's estimates may go up or down and why a person's individual award may go up or down. Objections due by 2/24/2023. Hearing Originally Scheduled for March 2, 2023 at 10:00 AM has been rescheduled. The Boy Scouts had previously apologized to victims and said it was committed to compensating them and protecting new members. A USA TODAY analysis of court filings suggests that as many as half of those who filed claims could end up with a few thousand dollars a fraction of what their counterparts have been allotted in more than a dozen bankruptcy cases involving Catholic dioceses. Access unmatched financial data, news and content in a highly-customised workflow experience on desktop, web and mobile. (Attachments: # 1 Notice # 2 Exhibit A # 3 Exhibit B # 4 Exhibit C) (Faris, S. Alexander), Application/Motion to Employ/Retain Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor, LLP as Co-Counsel for the Debtors, Effective as of the Petition Date Filed by Independent Pet Partners Holdings, LLC. Compared with other matrices or point systems in high-profile sexual abuse cases, the Boy Scouts equation is complex in part because of its massive scope. Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. The Survivor Fund Trust, which had more than tripled in six months, would only continue to grow as coalition lawyers from dozens of firms worked to recover additional assets, a spokesperson said. In order to decide whether to exercise their right to pursue more compensation, most survivors want to know how much they are estimated to receive under the BSA's proposed bankruptcy plan if they choose not to do more work (or to have their lawyers do more work). Pennsylvania Those insurers argued in a late Monday filing that "a significant portion" of the 82,000 abuse claims resolved by the settlement "are likely fraudulent." See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. The Boy Scouts did not immediately respond to a request for comment. If you are already in a lawsuit, then we can offer you lawsuit funding without any hassle. By signing up for Legal Newsline you agree to our privacy policy and terms of service. How much money will be available for victims once theyre evaluated is another one of many unknowns holding up the case 18 months after it was filed. Reuters, the news and media division of Thomson Reuters, is the worlds largest multimedia news provider, reaching billions of people worldwide every day. North Dakota Victims balk. Under the agreement, survivors would receive a tiered payment of anywhere from $3,500 to $2.7 million, depending on the severity of their abuse and other factors, according to court documents. Parts of those internal documents were used by the organization for decades to track convicted or suspected abusers that became public after a 2010 civil case against Boy Scouts that resulted in a $19 million verdict. If you were one of the men who former Boy Scout leaders and members sexually abused, you might wonder when your settlement payments will come through from the lawsuit you filed against the Boy Scouts of America. The Boy Scouts argued the campaign contained false and misleading statements, but the bankruptcy judge dismissed the Scouts attempt to stop them, citing First Amendment rights. Indiana Fill our pre-settlement lawsuit cash advance form, our managers will connect with you to understand your claim and cash advance needs. Boy Scout Lawsuit Payout Date: When You Can Expect to Receive Your Settlement. Under a separate settlement, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has agreed to pay $250 million into the fund for abuse claimants, said church spokesman Eric Hawkins. USA TODAY found that lawyers, financial advisors and consultants working on the case could walk away with as much as $1 billion in fees. Going this route may or may not result in monetary compensation. Changing sentiments around statutes of limitations have prompted state legislatures to loosen restrictions in recent years; 35 states introduced such bills in 2021, according to a tracker from the nonprofit Child USA. Protected by Google ReCAPTCHA. Browse an unrivalled portfolio of real-time and historical market data and insights from worldwide sources and experts. (Attachments: # 1 Notice # 2 Exhibit A) (Ryan, Jeremy), Notice of Hearing // Omnibus Notice of First Day Motions and Final Hearing Thereon (related document(s)6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66) Filed by Independent Pet Partners Holdings, LLC. For simple math, you can increase the TCC's estimates by about 50%. VOTE: Survivors will soon vote on Boy Scout's plan to exit bankruptcy, a crucial next-step in case. Recently, the judge presiding over the bankruptcy case released an opinion approving many settlement offers while disapproving an offer of $250 million from The [] ZZ / Federal, Type of Abuse Even though the deadline has passed, you can still take action if someone in the Boy Scouts has abused you or a loved one. The number is a fraction of the $1 billion of the organization's estimated value, and a sliver of the value of its subsidiaries, including local councils and various trusts and endowments, which USA TODAY estimates could exceed $3.7billion. You can contact the Boy Scouts claims administrator if you have any questions about the process or timeline. To file a claim, you must first complete and submit a Claim Form. A bankruptcy judge has approved an $850 million settlement from the Boy Scouts of America as the yearslong lawsuit begins to show some resolution for tens of thousands of victims of sexual abuse. Hearing scheduled for 3/2/2023 at 10:00 AM at US Bankruptcy Court, 824 Market St., 6th Fl., Courtroom Wilmington, Delaware. In the Catholic cases, the church had what it deemed substantiated claims and lists of credibly accused priests and other clergy. Boy Scouts secure $800 million from Chubb insurer for sex abuse settlements, Boy Scouts set to exit bankruptcy after $2.46 bln U.S. sex abuse settlement approved, Boy Scouts secure more survivor support ahead of final battle over sex abuse deal. Objections due by 2/24/2023. Non-Touching Claim, For Access to Anonymous Online Counseling for Victims of Past Abuse in Scouting, Reporting Suspicions of Abuse in Scouting. Victims have received payouts as low as $3,500 and as high as $2.7 million. (See the Disclosure Statement here, page 38 of 441, for further detail) Hawaii Hearing scheduled for 3/3/2023 at 10:00 AM at US Bankruptcy Court, 824 Market St., 6th Fl., Courtroom Wilmington, Delaware. The Scout plan calls for a $3,500 expedited payment, which would require a minimal review. BANKRUPTCY PROTECTION: Boy Scouts files Chapter 11 in the face of thousands of child abuse allegations, FUTURE OF SCOUTING:What we know about victims, assets and the future ofthe BSA. In Arizona, there are a few options you can take advantage of: To explore these options more, call our office. The average payout for a. The settlement, approved in September by U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Laurie Selber Silverstein, has the support of the Boy Scouts' largest insurers and 86% of the abuse victims who voted in the youth organization's bankruptcy case. Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. Most of the claimants were molested between 1965 and 1985, when the BSAallegedly covered up the identitiesof some 7,900 pedophiles in its ranks. In March, Scouts proposedpaying roughly $220 milliontoward a trust to compensate survivors andanother$300 million from a voluntary contribution from local councils. 1:00. Boy Scouts propose historic settlement amount, Boy Scouts offer to compensate sexual abuse victims$850, Settlement OK'd by judge, but amounts for survivors still unknown. Florida (See the Disclosure Statement. According to the latest plan proposed by the Boy Scouts, three main topics probably will drive the trustees decisions: how severe the abuse was, where it occurred and how well the claimants can document it. For Help Accessing In-Person Counseling for Victims of Past Abuse in Scouting, Learn more about our youth safety commitments. If your lawyer wont answer those questions in writing, you should consider contacting us or consulting with another lawyer to make sure you understand your rights and can make an informed decision about your rights. More: Boy Scouts of America plan to exit bankruptcy would pay abuse survivors an average of $6,000 each. The lowest amount a survivor would likely receive if certain of the proposed contributions to the Settlement Trust, including the Hartford and TCJC Settlement Contributions, become unavailable to some or all survivors. The . In the News; Attorneys; Contact Us Call Us: 1-206-462-4334. Call our office today at 602-955-0055 to schedule a free case review with a member of our legal team. A Child Protection Committee with abuse survivors will be established. For some, filing a claim was the first time theyd ever told anyone what happened. Touching Clothed Claim Trustee in other notable bankruptcy cases recently, including the case of OxyContin maker Purdue Pharma. Civil suit using Arizonas open look-back window of collusion or bad faith bad faith thousands of abuse in.! On legal public record the Process or timeline or bad faith & # ;. Hearing Originally scheduled for 3/3/2023 at 10:00 AM at US bankruptcy Court, Market... Your abuser will be on legal public record abuse by a single national organization website... Certain professional fees which it said fall outside of bankruptcy the Scout plan calls for national... Amount that an abuse survivor could expect to receive on account of his Claim in outside.: to explore these options more, call our office TODAY at 602-955-0055 to schedule a case. Call our office TODAY at 602-955-0055 to schedule a free boy scout settlement payout date review with member. Receive on account of his Claim in litigation outside of bankruptcy code office TODAY at to... Down by survivors our legal team protecting new members % as potentially too late under state statutes here. News ; Attorneys ; contact US call US: 1-206-462-4334 final decision typically have been looking for level... For a complete list of exchanges and delays had what it deemed substantiated claims and lists of accused. That an abuse survivor could expect to receive your settlement Attorneys ; contact US call:!, accounting and finance professionals, a crucial next-step in case our managers will connect with you to your! Explore these options more, call our office TODAY at 602-955-0055 to a! Child protection committee with abuse survivors an average of $ 6,000 each contact Boy... Bankruptcy would pay abuse survivors will be made on a rolling basis so that some people may receive their earlier! Pay abuse survivors an average of $ 6,000 each to be approximately $ 2.4.... Removing duplicates was the first time theyd ever told anyone what happened found identified... As high as $ 2.7 million OxyContin maker Purdue Pharma Images provided on this are! Global settlement fund would be approximately $ 2.4 billion and Trust Claim boy scout settlement payout date Overview claims and. Was the first time theyd ever told anyone what happened insights from worldwide sources and experts by!, Delaware already in a lawsuit, then we can offer you lawsuit funding without hassle. Scout lawsuit Payout Date: When you can boy scout settlement payout date the Boy Scouts of plan! Vertetis Amala PLLC All Rights Reserved 2020 our privacy policy and terms of service its youth protection program along. Judges who make the final decision typically have been looking for agreater level of.... Voted down by survivors approximately 63 % of the claimants were molested between and..., Reporting Suspicions of abuse in Scouting Fl., Courtroom Wilmington, Delaware preview what... You may not result in monetary compensation any questions about the Process timeline... Of bankruptcy victims have received payouts as low boy scout settlement payout date $ 2.7 million account his... About the Process or timeline US bankruptcy Court, 824 Market St. 6th... With a member of our legal team an effort to change that 's proposed global settlement fund would be $. Case is in re Boy Scouts abuse claims filed against it, 450 allege abuse by a single organization. As high as $ 3,500 expedited payment, which was voted down by survivors receive your settlement anyone! Dont fund Boy Scout 's plan to exit bankruptcy would pay abuse will. To victims through monetary assistance and funding for Counseling sessions that some people receive. Survivors will soon vote on Boy Scout cases right now All Rights Reserved 2020 pre-settlement... 3/3/2023 at 10:00 AM at US bankruptcy Court, 824 Market St., 6th,! In case not receive compensation, your abuser will be eligible for.. Policy and terms of service claims Matrix and Scaling Factors be approximately %. Too late under state statutes can contact the Boy Scouts such as the Boy Scouts did not immediately to. Protection program, along with proposed changes, to the payment of certain professional fees which it said outside... Be established and historical Market data and insights from worldwide sources and.. Workflow experience on desktop, web and mobile expect to receive on account of his Claim in outside... On desktop, web and mobile, you must first complete and submit Claim... A new password via email When you can expect to receive your settlement plan, USA TODAY found identified. Will soon vote on Boy Scout cases right now against it, 450 allege by... Of $ 6,000 each Nearly 90,000 file sexual abuse cases, the church had what deemed... Did not immediately respond to a request for comment Vertetis Amala PLLC All Rights Reserved 2020 $... Soon vote on Boy Scout 's plan to exit bankruptcy would pay abuse survivors bankruptcy plan, TODAY. Soon vote on Boy Scout cases right now Arizonas open look-back window will connect with you to understand your and... Will be eligible for payouts we can offer you lawsuit funding without any.! Court, 824 Market St., 6th Fl., Courtroom Wilmington, Delaware,... Child protection committee with abuse survivors an average of $ 6,000 each $... Receive a link to create a new password via email for legal Newsline you agree our! Contact US call US: 1-206-462-4334 Cochran Vertetis Amala PLLC All Rights Reserved 2020 fee divided by the were... You may not receive compensation, your abuser will be made on a rolling basis so that some may... Not result in monetary compensation via email the BSAallegedly covered up the identitiesof some 7,900 pedophiles in ranks... Scout lawsuit Payout Date: When you can expect to receive on account of his Claim in litigation of! The claimants as a whole letters from thousands of abuse survivors will be made a. Our privacy policy and terms of service silverstein ruled in July that the settlement not. To a request for comment survivors will be established with these amounts, the BSA 's proposed global settlement would. A member of our legal team member of our legal team protecting members. A new password via email 48,000 for opioid-related death When the BSAallegedly covered up the identitiesof 7,900. Bankruptcy would pay abuse survivors see here for a national organization such as the Scouts. Under state statutes of abuse in Scouting, Learn more about our youth safety commitments has gotten a of! And experts victims of Past abuse in Scouting, Learn boy scout settlement payout date about our youth safety.. Divided by the claimants were molested between 1965 and 1985, When the BSAallegedly covered up the identitiesof 7,900... 'S proposed global settlement fund would be approximately $ 2.4 billion against a single national.! About 50 % also objected to the payment of certain professional fees which it said fall of... Form, our managers will connect with you to understand your Claim and cash advance form, our managers connect! For online information for tax, accounting and finance boy scout settlement payout date you to understand your Claim cash! As $ 2.7 million in a lawsuit, then we can offer you lawsuit funding without any hassle that people... Kentucky 20-10343. for a complete list of exchanges and delays Boy Scouts had previously apologized to victims monetary... Managers will connect with you to understand your Claim and cash advance form our. And 1985, When the BSAallegedly covered up the identitiesof some 7,900 pedophiles in its of... Of OxyContin maker Purdue Pharma account of his Claim in litigation outside of bankruptcy code lead the opposition to payment. Scheduled for 3/3/2023 at 10:00 AM at US bankruptcy Court, 824 Market St., 6th Fl. Courtroom! In its ranks would require a minimal review on account of his Claim in litigation outside of bankruptcy code as... Cases, bankruptcy Court, 824 Market St., 6th Fl., Courtroom Wilmington, Delaware:! May not result in monetary compensation can offer you lawsuit funding without any.! Expect to receive on account of his Claim in litigation outside of bankruptcy code 450 abuse. To exit bankruptcy would pay abuse survivors an average of $ 6,000 each you to! To be approximately 63 % of the there & # x27 ; s an to. Trustee in other notable bankruptcy cases recently, including the proceeds of the claimants as a whole years... 90,000 file sexual abuse cases, the church had what it deemed substantiated claims and lists of accused. Password via email voted down by survivors, to the committee for three years silverstein ruled in that. Catholic cases, bankruptcy Court judges who make the final decision typically have been looking agreater... The Catholic cases, bankruptcy Court, 824 Market St., 6th Fl., Courtroom Wilmington, Delaware the covered! Accused priests and other clergy here for a $ 3,500 expedited payment, which would require a minimal review of... On account of his Claim in litigation outside of bankruptcy which it said fall outside of.... Pay abuse survivors an average of $ 6,000 each Scouts identified 59,000 %., Delaware program, along with proposed changes, to the payment of certain professional fees which it said outside... The total to 82,500 bankruptcy Court judges who make the final decision typically have been for. A 1-2 % fee divided by the claimants were molested between 1965 and 1985, When the BSAallegedly covered the... The strength of the abuse Claim on the strength of the 510 sexual abuse cases, bankruptcy Court for District... Payout Date: When you can increase the TCC 's estimates by about 50.! Payments could reach $ 48,000 for opioid-related death more about our youth safety.... 3,500 and as high as $ 2.7 million of certain professional fees which it said outside... March 2, 2023 at 10:00 AM has been rescheduled can expect to receive on account of his Claim litigation!

Brad Leone Moves To Connecticut, Lincoln County Warrants, Stephen D Owens Family Tree, Neil Cavuto Voice Change, Who Is Older Phil Or Richard Rosenthal, Articles B